The Boys, Widow's Bay Win Big at Critics Choice Super Awards 2026
· news
The Boys, Widow’s Bay Win Big at Critics Choice Super Awards 2026
The Critics Choice Super Awards have announced their winners for 2026, and genre content has finally taken center stage. The Boys and Widow’s Bay led the pack, each taking home three trophies, with Superman and Project Hail Mary also receiving recognition.
These awards were created in 2020 by CEO Joey Berlin to address the underrepresentation of genre content at traditional award shows like the Oscars and Emmys. By doing so, they aim to shine a spotlight on films and series that often get overlooked.
This year’s winners reflect a clear preference for superhero content, with The Boys tying Spider-Noir for Best Superhero Series. Antony Starr swept individual acting categories, winning both Best Actor in a Superhero Series and Best Villain in a Series. Widow’s Bay, meanwhile, took home three awards: Best Horror Series, Best Actor in a Horror Series for Matthew Rhys, and Best Actress in a Horror Series for Kate O’Flynn.
On the film side, Superman won top honors for Best Superhero Movie, with David Corenswet taking home Best Actor in a Superhero Movie. Project Hail Mary won both Best Science Fiction/Fantasy Movie and Best Actor in a Science Fiction/Fantasy Movie for Ryan Gosling. Obsession claimed Best Horror Movie and Best Actress in a Horror Movie for Inde Navarrette.
The Critics Choice Super Awards’ focus on genre content raises questions about the broader awards landscape. For years, prestige TV has dominated the Emmys, with shows like Breaking Bad and Game of Thrones leading the pack. However, with the rise of streaming platforms, we’re seeing a shift towards more specialized content – and it seems the Super Awards are trying to catch up.
The fact that these awards are separate from the main Critics Choice Awards is telling. The latter ceremony has historically prioritized prestige film and TV, while the Super Awards focus specifically on genre content. This bifurcation highlights the need to reevaluate what constitutes “prestige” – is it merely a matter of subject matter or artistic merit?
The impact of this year’s winners goes beyond just the nominees. It’s clear that genre content is no longer an afterthought – and as streaming continues to change the way we consume media, it’s only a matter of time before these awards gain even more prominence.
With the Critics Choice Super Awards set to return in 2027, it will be interesting to see whether they continue to prioritize genre content. Will the Oscars follow suit and give more attention to films like The Boys and Widow’s Bay? Only time will tell – but one thing is certain: the future of awards season looks bright, with superheroes leading the charge.
Reader Views
- CSCorrespondent S. Tan · field correspondent
The Critics Choice Super Awards' emphasis on genre content is both overdue and worrying - overdue because for years we've seen genre enthusiasts crying out for recognition, but worrying because it's still a niche awards show that doesn't quite address the root issue of industry snobbery. The real challenge lies in convincing voters to reward risk-taking content beyond the usual superhero franchises and prestige TV shows. Until they start recognizing emerging talent outside of established studios, these awards will remain more about patting themselves on the back than genuinely disrupting the status quo.
- CMColumnist M. Reid · opinion columnist
The Critics Choice Super Awards' emphasis on genre content raises valid questions about the broader awards landscape, but let's not get carried away with its perceived trend-setting power. The truth is, these awards often follow established streaming platforms' lead, recognizing trends that have already gained traction. A more nuanced analysis would examine how these separate awards actually influence the larger industry, rather than simply amplifying existing momentum.
- EKEditor K. Wells · editor
It's interesting to see genre content taking center stage at the Critics Choice Super Awards, but one can't help but wonder if this is merely a case of separating the wheat from the chaff rather than truly addressing the underrepresentation issue. By creating a separate awards show, are we simply acknowledging that mainstream awards shows will continue to prioritize prestige TV and blockbuster films, leaving genre content to fight for scraps?